Worcester Bosch vs Viessmann: Which Is the Best Boiler Brand?
Quick Answer: Both Worcester Bosch and Viessmann are premium boiler brands that consistently outscore the competition on reliability, efficiency, and warranty length. Viessmann edges ahead on raw efficiency — the Vitodens 200-W achieves up to 98% — and on warranty terms of up to 14 years. Worcester Bosch wins on brand recognition, installer availability, and the intelligent self-pressurising system built into the 8000 range. For most UK homes, either brand is an excellent choice; the best one depends on your property size, budget, and priorities. The Worcester Bosch Greenstar 28CDi features a compact design, making it an ideal option for smaller homes and apartments where space is limited. Its advanced heating controls allow for efficient energy use, ensuring that you get the most value from your investment. With a reputation for reliability and performance, this model is a popular choice among homeowners seeking a dependable heating solution.
Get a new boiler quote online here >
Introduction
Worcester Bosch and Viessmann are the two names that appear most consistently at the top of every credible UK boiler comparison — and for good reason. Both manufacturers offer A-rated condensing boilers with outstanding reliability records, long manufacturer warranties, smart thermostat compatibility, and hydrogen-ready credentials. Neither brand produces a bad boiler. The question is which one is right for your specific home and priorities. For those considering options like the Worcester Bosch Greenstar 25i review, it’s essential to look at the features that best fit your needs. The Greenstar 25i is known for its energy efficiency and compact design, making it ideal for smaller homes. Additionally, customer feedback often highlights its quiet operation and easy maintenance, contributing to its strong reputation in the market.
Worcester Bosch has been the dominant brand in the UK domestic market for decades. It holds the Which? Best Buy Award for more consecutive years than any other boiler manufacturer, and is installed in more UK homes than any competing brand. Viessmann is the challenger — a German engineering company with a strong commercial heritage that has brought its reputation for precision manufacturing to the domestic market, producing boilers that achieve higher efficiency ratings than Worcester Bosch’s equivalent models. Alpha boilers customer satisfaction ratings indicate a growing preference for Viessmann as consumers seek efficiency and reliability. As more homeowners share their experiences, it becomes clear that Viessmann’s innovative design and performance are making a significant impact in the market. This trend suggests a potential shift in consumer loyalty as buyers become increasingly discerning about their heating solutions.
This guide compares the two brands directly across key purchase criteria — efficiency, warranty, product range, reliability, smart controls, price, and available installer support — to help you make a fully informed decision.
Understanding the Comparison: The Core Relationships
The Worcester Bosch vs Viessmann comparison involves several interconnected factors that together determine which brand is the better match for a specific household.
- Worcester Bosch is a UK-based subsidiary of the Bosch Group that has held the Which? Best Buy Award for central heating boilers for over 10 consecutive years, reflecting consistently strong customer satisfaction and reliability ratings across its domestic boiler range.
- Viessmann is a German family-owned engineering company founded in 1917 that manufactures domestic and commercial heating equipment, bringing a heritage of precision manufacturing to a domestic combi boiler range that achieves efficiency ratings among the highest available in the UK market.
- The Viessmann Vitodens 200-W achieves up to 98% efficiency using its MatriX cylinder burner and advanced modulation technology — the highest efficiency rating available on any domestic gas combi boiler in the UK in 2026.
- The Worcester Bosch Greenstar 8000 achieves 94% efficiency and includes the Intelligent Filling System as standard, which monitors sealed system pressure and repressurises automatically without manual intervention.
- A manufacturer’s warranty on a Worcester Bosch boiler runs up to 10 years when installed by a Worcester Bosch-accredited engineer — competitive in the market but shorter than Viessmann’s maximum available terms.
- A manufacturer’s warranty on a Viessmann boiler runs up to 14 years when installed by a Viessmann-accredited engineer — among the longest domestic boiler warranties available from any manufacturer in the UK.
- A Which? Best Buy Award is an independent consumer endorsement based on reliability data, customer satisfaction scores, and performance testing — Worcester Bosch holds this status across its boiler range; Viessmann’s Vitodens 100-W also holds Which? Best Buy status.
- Boiler Plus compliance is a legal requirement for all new UK gas boiler installations — both Worcester Bosch and Viessmann boilers comply with the 92% minimum efficiency and advanced controls requirements of this standard.
- A Gas Safe-registered engineer must carry out any gas boiler installation — accredited installers from both manufacturers can unlock the maximum available warranty terms, making installer selection important to the warranty outcome.
- Hydrogen readiness to a 20% blend is standard across both manufacturers’ current combi and system boiler ranges, future-proofing installations from either brand against the planned partial transition of the UK gas network.
- Smart thermostat integration is available from both brands — Worcester Bosch offers the Wave and EasyControl platforms; Viessmann offers the ViCare app and Vitodens-specific controls — both of which enable remote heating management via smartphone.
- Annual boiler servicing is required by both manufacturers to maintain warranty validity, with a Gas Safe engineer carrying out the service and completing the required documentation each year.
Brand Overview
Worcester Bosch
Worcester Bosch has been manufacturing boilers in the UK since 1962 and remains the market leader in domestic gas boiler installations by volume. Its Greenstar range spans combi, system, and regular boiler configurations from entry-level to premium, covering every common property type and output requirement. Worcester Bosch Greenstar features explained provide insights into the technology and efficiency behind these popular models. Each boiler in the range is designed with advanced features aimed at maximizing performance while minimizing energy consumption. Homeowners can benefit from a variety of options tailored to meet their specific heating needs, ensuring optimal comfort throughout the year.
The brand’s strength is its combination of trusted reliability, reinforced by more than 10 consecutive Which? Best Buy Awards — with the widest installer network of any boiler manufacturer in the UK. Worcester Bosch-accredited installers operate nationwide, ensuring that access to qualified engineers for installation, servicing, and warranty repairs is available in virtually every area.
Worcester Bosch boilers are German-engineered and manufactured in Worcester, combining the quality standards associated with the Bosch Group with the domestic market knowledge built over 60 years of UK operation. When considering Worcester Bosch system boiler reviews, many users highlight their energy efficiency and reliability, making them a popular choice among homeowners. Additionally, the range of models available caters to various heating needs, ensuring that there is an appropriate solution for both small and large properties. This combination of performance and adaptability solidifies Worcester Bosch’s reputation in the competitive UK market. When exploring Worcester Bosch boiler performance reviews, customers often emphasize the low noise levels during operation, which enhances comfort within the home. Moreover, the extensive warranty options provided by Worcester Bosch give homeowners peace of mind, further bolstering their confidence in the product’s durability. As a result, these factors contribute to a strong sense of satisfaction among users, establishing Worcester Bosch as a trusted brand in the industry.
Viessmann
Viessmann was founded in Germany in 1917 and has been manufacturing heating technology for over 100 years. Its domestic boiler range is built around the Vitodens series — stainless steel heat-exchanger combi and system boilers that bring the precision-engineering heritage of Viessmann’s commercial and industrial heating to residential installations. Viessmann Vitodens 200W features overview highlights the advanced technology and efficiency that define this model. Designed to meet the varying demands of modern homes, the Vitodens 200W combines energy-saving features with user-friendly controls. Furthermore, its compact design allows for installation in tight spaces, making it an ideal choice for urban settings.
Viessmann entered the UK domestic mass market relatively recently compared to Worcester Bosch, but its Vitodens 100-W has achieved Which? Best Buy status and the range consistently achieve the highest available efficiency ratings. The brand’s emphasis is on engineering quality, efficiency, leadership, and long warranty terms rather than the broadest installer network. In light of the increasing competition, a thorough worcester 4000 review and performance analysis will help potential buyers make an informed decision. Users often express admiration for its reliability and ease of use, noting how it stands out in various testing scenarios. As energy efficiency becomes more critical for homeowners, the features of models like the worcester 4000 will play an essential role in shaping future purchases.
Head-to-Head Comparison
Efficiency
Viessmann wins.
Viessmann produces the most efficient domestic gas boilers available in the UK. The Vitodens 200-W achieves up to 98% efficiency — the highest rating of any domestic combi boiler on the UK market. The Vitodens 100-W achieves 94%, matching Worcester Bosch’s premium Greenstar 8000 model. The entry-level Vitodens 050-W achieves 92%, meeting the Boiler Plus minimum but not exceptional. In addition to these models, the Worcester Bosch Greenstar 36CDi features advanced heating technology that ensures both efficiency and reliability for modern homes. Its compact design makes it a suitable choice for tight spaces, while its suite of smart control options enhances user convenience. With robust performance and eco-friendly credentials, it stands out as a competitive alternative in the domestic boiler market.
Worcester Bosch’s Greenstar range achieves 92% to 94% across its product line. There are no Worcester Bosch models that match the Vitodens 200-W’s 98% peak efficiency. The Worcester Bosch CDi Compact features advanced technology designed for space-saving installations and efficient heating. With its compact design, it is ideal for smaller properties, providing homeowners with an excellent balance of performance and efficiency. This model is particularly praised for its reliability and ease of installation, making it a favored choice among professionals. The Worcester Bosch Greenstar 30i features impressive energy efficiency and a user-friendly interface that simplifies operation. Homeowners appreciate the quiet performance, ensuring minimal disruption while maintaining comfort. Additionally, its environmentally friendly credentials reflect a growing commitment to sustainable heating solutions in the industry.
For high-gas-consumption properties where every percentage point of efficiency translates into meaningful annual savings, Viessmann’s efficiency advantage is significant. For average- to lower-consumption homes, the practical difference between 94% and 94% is negligible.
| Model | Brand | Efficiency |
|---|---|---|
| Viessmann Vitodens 200-W | Viessmann | Up to 98% |
| Viessmann Vitodens 100-W | Viessmann | 94% |
| Worcester Bosch Greenstar 8000 | Worcester Bosch | 94% |
| Viessmann Vitodens 050-W | Viessmann | 92% |
| Worcester Bosch Greenstar 4000 | Worcester Bosch | 92% |
Warranty
Viessmann wins.
Viessmann offers up to 14 years warranty on its Vitodens range when installed by a Viessmann-accredited engineer — one of the longest domestic boiler warranties available from any manufacturer in the UK. Worcester Bosch offers up to 10 years on its premium Greenstar 8000 range when installed by an accredited engineer. Worcester Bosch boiler efficiency ratings are among the highest in the industry, making them a popular choice for homeowners looking to reduce energy consumption. With advanced technology and innovative designs, these boilers not only provide effective heating but also contribute to lower carbon footprints. As energy prices continue to rise, investing in a high-efficiency model can lead to significant long-term savings.
Both warranties are manufacturer-backed and require annual servicing by a Gas Safe-registered engineer to remain valid. The additional 4 years of Viessmann coverage provides meaningful protection against the component failure costs most likely to arise in the 10 to 14-year window of a boiler’s life. Understanding viessmann boiler efficiency ratings in detail can help homeowners make informed decisions when selecting the right model for their needs. High efficiency ratings not only indicate lower energy consumption but also translate to cost savings over time. As a result, investing in a boiler with superior efficiency can prove to be beneficial in both the short and long term. viessmann boiler pricing for homeowners can vary significantly depending on the model and features selected. Homeowners should also take into account installation costs and potential rebates, which can further affect the overall investment. By comparing different models and understanding the pricing structure, homeowners can find a solution that fits their budget while ensuring optimal performance.
| Brand | Standard Warranty | Maximum Warranty (Accredited Install) |
|---|---|---|
| Viessmann | 5 years | Up to 14 years |
| Worcester Bosch | 5 years | Up to 10 years |
Reliability
Worcester Bosch wins — marginally.
Worcester Bosch’s 10+ consecutive Which? Best Buy Awards reflect sustained performance across a large installed base — millions of UK homes — over many years. The brand’s reputation for reliability is well-established, backed by a long track record of UK domestic installations at scale.
Viessmann’s Vitodens 100-W also holds Which? Best Buy’s status and the brand’s engineering quality are extremely high. However, Viessmann’s UK domestic installed base is smaller than Worcester Bosch’s, meaning the reliability dataset at scale is less extensive. The stainless steel Inox-Radial heat exchanger used across the Vitodens range is widely considered among the most durable available by heating engineers. When considering Viessmann Vitodens 050 pricing details, it’s essential to evaluate the features that justify the investment. The Vitodens 050 offers advanced modulation technology, which enhances efficiency and reduces energy costs. Moreover, its compact design makes it an ideal choice for homeowners with limited space.
Both brands are reliably above average compared to the broader market. The difference in reliability between them is marginal — both significantly outperform most budget and mid-range competitors.
Product Range
Worcester Bosch wins.
Worcester Bosch offers a broader product range than Viessmann for the UK domestic market — combi, system, and regular boilers across three tiers (2000, 4000, 8000), spanning output sizes from 18kW to 50kW and price points from entry-level to premium. This breadth means Worcester Bosch has a specific model suited to virtually every property type and budget. Worcester Bosch combi boiler features include advanced energy efficiency technology and user-friendly controls, making them a popular choice among homeowners. Additionally, these boilers are designed for compact spaces, ensuring that even smaller homes can benefit from high-performance heating solutions. With a robust warranty and excellent customer service, Worcester Bosch continues to lead the market in reliability and customer satisfaction.
Viessmann’s UK domestic range is more focused — centred on the Vitodens 050-W, 100-W, and 200-W — with fewer models at each price tier. This focus means the Viessmann range is simpler to navigate, but offers fewer options at the budget end of the market. The viessmann 35kw boiler features explained include its energy efficiency and advanced technology, making it suitable for various heating needs. Additionally, its compact design allows for easy installation in smaller spaces, while maintaining powerful performance. Customers appreciate the reliability and long lifespan associated with Viessmann products, ensuring peace of mind with their investment. viessmann 20kw boiler specifications highlight its versatility, making it a strong contender for medium-sized homes. With features designed to optimize energy usage, this model not only reduces heating costs but also supports environmental sustainability. Users can expect a quiet operation and user-friendly controls, enhancing the overall user experience.
Smart Controls
Draw — both brands excel.
Worcester Bosch’s EasyControl and Wave smart thermostats integrate directly with Greenstar boilers and enable load compensation, weather compensation, remote control via smartphone, and geolocation-based heating management. The Intelligent Filling System on the 8000 range adds automatic repressurisation — a genuine practical convenience that no Viessmann model currently matches. The Worcester Bosch Greenstar 25Si features a compact design that is ideal for smaller homes or apartments, making it a great choice for those looking to save space. Its energy efficiency helps reduce heating costs while maintaining a comfortable environment, ensuring homeowners can enjoy both savings and warmth. Additionally, the unit is compatible with various smart home devices, further enhancing its appeal in the modern energy landscape.
Viessmann’s ViCare app and Vitodens-specific controls offer equivalent remote management, scheduling, and energy monitoring. Load and weather compensation are available on Vitodens models. Both platforms are well-regarded by users and compatible with third-party smart thermostats including Hive and Nest.
Price
Worcester Bosch wins for value; Viessmann commands a premium.
Worcester Bosch’s Greenstar range offers strong performance at slightly lower price points than the equivalent Viessmann Vitodens models. The Greenstar 4000 provides competitive efficiency at an accessible price for mid-budget buyers. The Greenstar 8000 competes directly with the Vitodens 100-W at a similar price point. The Worcester Bosch Greenstar 8000 features advanced technology that enhances both energy efficiency and user control. With its modern design and smart connectivity options, it appeals to tech-savvy homeowners looking for reliable heating solutions. Additionally, the Greenstar 8000’s compact size makes it an ideal choice for properties with limited installation space. When considering Worcester Bosch boiler efficiency ratings, homeowners will find that both the Greenstar 4000 and 8000 models stand out for their high performance and low running costs. These ratings highlight the brand’s commitment to sustainability, making them a top choice for environmentally conscious consumers. Furthermore, the impressive efficiency ratings ensure that homeowners can enjoy significant savings on their energy bills while maintaining a comfortable living environment.
Viessmann’s Vitodens 050-W offers an entry-level price point, but the 100-W and 200-W models command a premium reflecting their engineering quality and warranty terms. For buyers who prioritise the highest efficiency and longest warranty available, the premium is justifiable. For buyers prioritising brand reputation and installer availability, Worcester Bosch delivers equivalent satisfaction at slightly lower cost. The viessmann vitodens 100w features overview highlights its exceptional efficiency ratings and advanced technology, making it a popular choice among homeowners seeking to reduce energy costs. Additionally, the robust build quality and user-friendly controls set it apart from many competitors in its class, ensuring reliable performance over the years. With these advantages, the 100w appeals not only to efficiency-minded consumers but also to those looking for long-term investment value.
Installer Availability
Worcester Bosch wins convincingly.
Worcester Bosch has the largest network of accredited installers in the UK — a direct consequence of being the market leader by volume for decades. Accredited Worcester Bosch installers are available in virtually every UK postcode, making it straightforward to find a qualified engineer for installation, annual servicing, and warranty repairs.
Viessmann’s accredited installer network is growing but remains smaller than Worcester Bosch’s. In most major UK cities and towns, finding a Viessmann-accredited engineer is straightforward. In more rural areas, the search may require more effort or a longer wait time.
For buyers who prioritise the maximum warranty terms and plan to use accredited engineers exclusively, this is a practical consideration worth checking before committing to either brand.
Summary Scorecard
| Criterion | Worcester Bosch | Viessmann | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peak efficiency | 94% | Up to 98% | Viessmann |
| Maximum warranty | 10 years | 14 years | Viessmann |
| Which? Best Buy | Yes (10+ years) | Yes (Vitodens 100-W) | Draw |
| Reliability record | Extensive UK data | Strong but smaller base | Worcester Bosch |
| Product range breadth | Wide | Focused | Worcester Bosch |
| Smart controls | Excellent | Excellent | Draw |
| Installer availability | Excellent (nationwide) | Good (major areas) | Worcester Bosch |
| Price vs performance | Strong | Premium priced | Worcester Bosch |
| Hydrogen ready | Yes (20% blend) | Yes (20% blend) | Draw |
Which Brand Should You Choose?
Choose Viessmann if:
- Maximum efficiency is your primary criterion, and you want the best available rating on the market.
- You want the longest possible warranty — up to 14 years provides the greatest long-term financial protection.
- You have a high-gas-consumption property where the efficiency premium of the Vitodens 200-W translates into meaningful annual savings.
- A Viessmann-accredited installer is available in your area and can be confirmed before committing.
Choose Worcester Bosch if:
- Brand reliability, reputation, and the longest track record of Which? Best Buy endorsements matter most to you.
- You want the widest choice of accredited installers, particularly in rural or less populated areas.
- You value the Intelligent Filling System — automatic repressurisation is a genuinely useful feature for hands-off homeowners.
- You want strong performance at a slightly lower price than the equivalent Viessmann models.
- You prefer a broader product range with more model choices at each price tier.
For most 3– to 4-bedroom UK homes, either the Worcester Bosch Greenstar 8000 or the Viessmann Vitodens 100-W is an excellent choice — both achieve 94% efficiency and hold Which? Best Buy status, and both provide a long warranty when installed by an accredited engineer. The difference between them in practical daily operation is small enough that installer availability and price at the time of purchase are legitimate tiebreakers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Worcester Bosch or Viessmann better?
Both are premium boiler brands that significantly outperform most of the market on reliability, efficiency, and warranty. Viessmann edges ahead on efficiency — the Vitodens 200-W achieves up to 98% — and warranty length, offering up to 14 years versus Worcester Bosch’s 10 years maximum. Worcester Bosch leads in brand recognition, installer availability, and breadth of product range. For most UK homeowners, either brand is an excellent choice — the best one depends on whether efficiency or installer access is the higher priority. To ensure that you receive the best service possible, you should consider the various Worcester Bosch service booking options available in your area. Many customers report high satisfaction with the ease of scheduling and the professionalism of the technicians. By choosing the right service package, you can maintain your boiler’s performance and prolong its lifespan.
Which boiler brand is most reliable?
Worcester Bosch has the most extensively documented reliability record in the UK domestic market, backed by 10 or more consecutive Which? Best Buy Awards and the largest installed base of any boiler brand in the country. Viessmann’s Vitodens range also holds Which? Best Buy status, and is built around a stainless steel heat exchanger, widely regarded by heating engineers as among the most durable available. Both brands are reliably above average; the difference between them is marginal compared to their shared advantage over most budget and mid-range competitors. when considering the viessmann vitodens 222f specifications, it’s important to note its high-efficiency rating and compatibility with smart home systems, which makes it an appealing choice for modern households. Additionally, the Vitodens 222F features a compact design, allowing for easy installation in various spaces, which is a crucial factor for many homeowners. As energy efficiency continues to be a priority, Viessmann’s commitment to innovation positions it strongly in the market.
How long is the warranty on Worcester Bosch vs Viessmann?
Worcester Bosch offers up to 10 years’ warranty on its premium Greenstar 8000 range when installed by a Worcester Bosch-accredited engineer. Viessmann offers up to 14 years’ warranty on its Vitodens range when installed by a Viessmann-accredited engineer. Both require annual servicing by a Gas Safe engineer to keep the warranty valid. The standard warranty without accredited installation is 5 years for both brands. Worcester Bosch boiler efficiency ratings are among the highest in the industry, making them a popular choice for homeowners seeking cost-effective heating solutions. This impressive efficiency not only reduces energy bills but also contributes to a lower carbon footprint. When selecting a boiler, it’s essential to consider these ratings along with installation and servicing options to ensure optimal performance.
Which is more efficient — Worcester Bosch or Viessmann?
Viessmann produces more efficient boilers. The Vitodens 200-W achieves up to 98% efficiency — the highest available on any domestic gas combi boiler in the UK. The Vitodens 100-W achieves 94%, matching Worcester Bosch’s most efficient model, the Greenstar 8000. Worcester Bosch’s Greenstar 4000 achieves 92%, the Boiler Plus minimum. For homeowners who prioritise maximum efficiency, Viessmann offers the highest achievable rating at each price tier. Worcester Bosch Greenstar boiler performance is commendable, especially with models like the Greenstar 8000 and 4000. In addition to their efficiency ratings, these boilers are designed for reliability and durability, catering well to the needs of modern homes. Homeowners can benefit from the advanced features that enhance both comfort and energy savings year-round.
Are Worcester Bosch and Viessmann boilers hydrogen-ready?
Yes — both Worcester Bosch and Viessmann boilers are hydrogen-ready to a 20% blend as standard across their current ranges. This means both brands’ boilers can operate on a gas supply containing up to 20% hydrogen without modification, future-proofing the installation against the planned partial transition of the UK gas network. Neither brand currently produces a domestic boiler certified for 100% hydrogen operation, as this technology is still in development across the industry. In addition to their hydrogen readiness, the Viessmann Vitodens 111W performance review highlights its efficiency ratings and advanced features designed to optimize energy consumption. Users have praised its user-friendly interface and reliability, making it a popular choice among homeowners seeking sustainable heating solutions. As the industry evolves, the focus on reducing carbon emissions will likely drive further innovations in boiler technology.
What is the best Worcester Bosch or Viessmann boiler for a 3-bedroom house?
For a 3-bedroom house with one bathroom, the Worcester Bosch Greenstar 8000 28kW or 30kW and the Viessmann Vitodens 100-W 26kW or 30kW are both excellent choices. Both achieve 94% efficiency, hold Which? Best Buy status, and carry warranties of 10 to 14 years when installed by an accredited engineer. The Worcester Bosch adds the Intelligent Filling System; the Viessmann adds 4 additional years of warranty protection. Either serves a standard 3-bedroom home outstandingly well for 12 to 15 years.
Conclusion: Two Outstanding Brands, One Practical Decision
The Worcester Bosch vs Viessmann debate does not have a wrong answer. Both brands produce boilers that will reliably and efficiently heat a UK home for 12 to 15 years, backed by warranties that reflect genuine manufacturer confidence in their products. The difference between them is meaningful at the margins — efficiency, warranty length, and installer availability — but not significant enough to make the losing choice a bad one. When considering the options, a baxi boiler efficiency analysis reveals that while Baxi models may not lead the pack, they offer solid performance metrics that appeal to those looking for value. Customers often appreciate the balance between cost and efficiency, especially in systems designed for residential heating. Ultimately, the decision may come down to specific heating needs and the availability of qualified installers in one’s area.
Viessmann is the choice for buyers who prioritise engineering excellence, maximum efficiency, and the longest available warranty. Worcester Bosch is the choice for buyers who prioritise proven brand reliability, nationwide access to installers, and the broadest product range at a competitive price. Understanding Viessmann boiler error codes explained can be crucial for maintaining optimal performance and ensuring longevity. By identifying specific error codes, users can troubleshoot issues effectively and know when to contact a professional. This knowledge not only saves time but also enhances the overall user experience with Viessmann products.
Before making a final decision, confirm the availability of accredited installers for both brands in your postcode, compare quotes for equivalent models, and verify warranty terms at the time of purchase. Both brands are worth every penny of their premium over budget alternatives — the choice between them is the kind of problem that only arises when both options are genuinely good.











